Ad placeholder

Talk:Astarion: Difference between revisions

Jump to navigation Jump to search
Tags: Mobile edit Mobile web edit Reply Source
Tags: Reply Source
Line 17: Line 17:
::As for Neil, I also find the subject touchy because in the past there have been a few instances of him getting info about Astarion wrong based on people's fan content. I admit there's some personal bias there in that in regards to lore canon I prioritise what the writers have to say (and in all honesty I fully expect Rooney to confirm he was a noble, because as we pointed out it's the most logical conclusion, but we don't have that statement, I believe) [[Special:Contributions/31.4.198.250|31.4.198.250]] 12:30, 9 January 2025 (CET)
::As for Neil, I also find the subject touchy because in the past there have been a few instances of him getting info about Astarion wrong based on people's fan content. I admit there's some personal bias there in that in regards to lore canon I prioritise what the writers have to say (and in all honesty I fully expect Rooney to confirm he was a noble, because as we pointed out it's the most logical conclusion, but we don't have that statement, I believe) [[Special:Contributions/31.4.198.250|31.4.198.250]] 12:30, 9 January 2025 (CET)
:::Just realised the different IP must look suspicious. I went out and I'm using data. [[Special:Contributions/31.4.198.250|31.4.198.250]] 12:34, 9 January 2025 (CET)
:::Just realised the different IP must look suspicious. I went out and I'm using data. [[Special:Contributions/31.4.198.250|31.4.198.250]] 12:34, 9 January 2025 (CET)
::::Please consider creating an account, that would make discussing much easier.
::::I agree that it could be speculated that Astarion a noble, but the evidence, we have is not enough. Because being a Magistrate does not neccessarily mean being a noble. And that he had the noble background in EA is not that relevant because Larian changed it, so it is no longer canon as it was mentioned before. And Neil Newbon seems, in this case, as it was said before, not a valid source for this particular information.
::::So I would move the whole thing in the Notes section.
::::And imho the cards should be moved below the gallery section, at best as part (or under section) of the gallery. [[User:Hawkeye|Hawkeye]] ([[User talk:Hawkeye|talk]]) 14:18, 9 January 2025 (CET)
23,706
edits

Navigation menu