Punish the Wicked is a quest in Chapter Two of Baldur's Gate 3. It can be started by speaking with He Who Was in the Shadowed Battlefield.
 | Spoiler warning: The following content contains unhidden spoilers. Read at your own risk. |
Objectives
- Find the ledger.
- He Who Was wants to bring justice to the victims of a murderer - to do so, he needs a ledger belonging to the killer. It is hidden in the Waning Moon.
- Give the ledger to He Who Was.
- We found the ledger. We should give it to He Who Was.
- We gave the ledger to He Who Was and punished the killer for her crimes. He was pleased.
- We refused to give the ledger to He Who Was, and do not know what became of him.
- He Who Was is no more.
- He Who Was wanted Madeline punished - we forgave her instead. He was furious.
- We forced He Who Was to stab himself over and over again during the ritual. He was furious.
- We left the shadowlands and may never know what became of He Who Was.